I really really REALLY hope you're not older than me, because that is honest the saddest & most pathetic thing I've read here today. You act like a kid, you argue like a kid, and you're as naive as a kid. The best thing you could have done for yourself is claim to be 12 & let the adults talk now. You claim to be a content creator who loves open source, but i'm just curious; If you create things for people who never actually pay you, how do you live? How can you actually code that software to begin with if you're not receiving an income from it? How does a game or MMO start production if nobody has funded it and the budget is whatever change they've got in their pocket?
When companies add DRM or piracy protection to software, they pay money to a DRM software provider to provide that protection in addition to paying them royalties. The adding of DRM costs EXTRA and prices over the past 10 years (as apposed to the 10 years prior to that) are severely inflated in EXCESS of what would be caused by inflation alone. How much is a PC game today? ~$80-90 on release. How much was it 10 years ago? ~$60-70 and none of those games had DRM. How much were the games 10 years before that? Guess what? They were still $60-70. So if inflation alone barely budged the prices for the gaming industry over 20 years but Piracy has increased that inflation tenfold in the years since then, hrmmmmm i wonder what exactly that means... Dammit i knew there was some correlation between piracy & prices i was trying to make...
This is also completely ignoring the fact that the prices are also increased to compensate for lower expected sales. Compared to consoles, over the past few years PC sales have gone DOWN & PC prices have gone UP to compensate. That is an absolute fact. Just because 1,000,000 people aren't going to pay you a cent for it and will instead download it for free, doesn't mean your budget or the amount you spent creating it has gone down. You still need to make back the exact same amount, except you know that you'll get 1,000,000 people not paying which means the price for everyone else has to go UP. That's simple economics even a primary school student can understand. You also fail to understand that when someone has FUNDED the project (ie. they like the proposal & agreed to pay for the project assuming they will make that money back + profit) that means giving it out as open-source simply isn't an option. Because unlike the basement-coded apps & indie games this actually cost ALOT of money to make.
"HA HA, sorry I cannot do anything except laugh extremely hard at your post (at least the beginning)!!! Seriously, comparing piracy to child porn Wow... You surely have some audacity..."
No, no i did not. Do you even know what a comparison is? It was a stated fact. Piracy IS one of THE WORST things to have ever happened to the internet. More money has been lost this way than by any other means, and it HAS affected several studios enough to force them to close.
"Your little comparison of stealing from a brick and mortar store is a completely different argument, that IS stealing. If you take a car, or a compact disc, or a computer that is a (or any other) tangible item and IS plain and simply theft. When you 'copy' data you're not really depriving anyone else of it, you're not 'taking' it, therefore you're essentially not 'stealing' it."
The person standing in line infront of you was just asked to pay $1,000 for that piece of software you've just stuffed into your jacket & will install at home for free. Regardless of how much you rationalize that even if it was a tangible object it would only cost 50c to burn to a CD, the CONTENT of that CD cost MILLIONS to create and in order to use it the publishers are asking that you give them a portion of that back as thanks for them creating it for you. Someone paid millions of dollars to fund the project, someone had to pay salaries to all of the programmers who coded it, yet you think you are still ENTITLED to get that software for free while everyone else pays for it?
As for your technology debate... Don't make me laugh. A PC 10 years ago cost the same as a PC today. Difference is, the PC from today is ~100x more powerful. Go forward 10 years, and the same cost is associated with making this PC. New tech always cost the same, it then drops as it becomes mainstream & again when it's obsolete. Today's PC is easier to afford due to people EARNING MORE MONEY, but the price of the item itself has not changed, the buying power of the population has.
You an 'adult', dude your testicles haven't even dropped yet <.< I may not be old enough to be your daddy, but I have almost TEN years on you, so YOU grow up, let your testicles drop, live and learn a little, THEN come back and talk to me... I am a content creator, and I'll tell you what: I make my money off of SERVICES or the TANGIBLE items I sell. All my "intellectual property" I do not charge for... So yes, I am NOT a GREEDY duck like the industry, and apparently YOU. Now can you tell me THIS, HOW and WHY is UNIX/LINUX (not only open source but,) BETTER than windows, yet FREE
OMG how is this possible, NO WAY... >.< Wait wait wait,
You must be registered to see links
hmm yea, W7UF LIST PRICE is $320 (holy poop it's SOFTware for gods sake), ok lets see here now,
You must be registered to see links
wait no sorry no charge, "free to download" hmm - that's odd... (I only used them as an example, there are PLENTY of other FREE as in FREE BEER AND FREE SPEECH distros out there)...
I am NOT buying into your theory about piracy driving prices dramatically higher. While I NEVER said it doesn't play a role at ALL, it has not raised software $30 per title, you're NOT paying $30 extra PER title had piracy never existed... If you think you are than you're just plain ignorant... However, I've said before MYSELF that "COMPANIES WASTE MONEY ON © PROTECTION, AND THAT'S ALL IT IS IS A WASTE BECAUSE WHILE IT MAY STOP PEOPLE FOR AN HOUR OR A DAY OR A WEEK OR A MONTH IT WILL NOT STOP THEM FOREVER, so it's a WASTE, so thank you for actually further proving MY point. WHY on gods green earth are they WASTING money on © protection when it is INEVITABLE that SOME people will COPY (NOT STEAL) it NO MATTER WHAT... Furthermore we're NOT going to talk about 10 years ago, because you were HARDLY above 10 years old at the time, so yes, you're hysterically deluded! I don't even want to talk about NOW with you any more because I don't know where the duck you're getting your games today, but if you're paying $80 and $90 a game WOW are you taking it up the rear! Games are still about ~$60/$70 on launch... (
PROOF: examples:
You must be registered to see links
[not even out yet for a few more days $60],
You must be registered to see links
[also not out yet $40],
You must be registered to see links
[$60],
You must be registered to see links
[$60],
You must be registered to see links
[$60], wait, this one is quite a ways from launch
You must be registered to see links
[$60], HELL browse the whole UPCOMING list HERE:
You must be registered to see links
and you will not see ANYTHING above $60 (NOT including collectors/deluxe/premium editions which do NOT apply for purposes of THIS conversation topic))
Your next paragraph just further illustrates MY point that "THE INDUSTRY" is a bunch of GREEDY FUCKS. In NO ("intellectual rights") industry should prices be adjusted based on projected sales. Well hmm Bob if we're only gonna possibly sell this to 1,000,000 people we need to charge $500 per copy in order to make any kind of profit on it. Or, hey Bob if we're gonna possibly sell this to 10,000,000 we can charge $50 per copy... Greedy shits, how about make your 'real money' off TANGIBLES, SERVICES, ETC... (for the billionth time) So while THEY get to be the GREEDY FUCKS that demand THEY WANT X for Y product, when they play it that way they will get their $500,000,000 no matter whether YOU the little end user has to pay $50 or $500 -- GREED -- at it's BEST!!!
That's fine, perhaps I shouldn't have used to word 'COMPARE' but then again A) I was bound to make SOME errors in a such a long post, and B) I should have known someone like YOU would have attempted to PICK IT APART WITH A MICROSCOPE... However NO piracy is NOT the worst thing or even ONE OF the worst things to "happen to the internet" piracy was around WAY before the interwebz. Again, you must not have much of an education on ANYTHING that happened prior to your short, hardly over 20 year, life... BOOKS were initially viewed as piracy, it's part of history... So I hate to break it to you but piracy was around LONG before you or the interwebz. It will be around (in whatever form) even after the internet, should anything ever happen to it... ... ... However, again, even though you may not have "COMPARED" them to even mention child pron and piracy in the same sentence makes you plain and simply a sick duck! You clearly do NOT have kids... Even if you did, you'd just be a kid with a kid.
Ok, I don't know if you have a learning disability but, again BRICK AND MORTAR STORE v COPYING SOFTWARE ONLINE, != the same ball park. Sorry kid, but it would not (and actually does not) cost me hardly anything to DIGITALLY distribute my own works, meanwhile it DOES if I want to have it stamped onto a disc, put in a pretty shiny little box, loaded with pretty little box art that some printing company had to print a billion copies of too for me, then all loaded into trucks and driven all around the place, air planes and/or boats to get the poop overseas, more tucks and or trains -- but wait, after I write a "program" I can click here, then there, write a description, and HOLY poop -- the whole world can download it. OMG this is assanine I wanted $320 per copy >.<
Again, we're not gonna talk about 10 years ago because I realize you were hardly above 10 years old... <>END OF LINE<> Oh wait, you're too young to get that one too (I'd be surprised if you even understood my Johnny Five reference, that was 3 years before you were even born)
~
Point is you're clearly clouded and you don't realize that there are always two sides to a fence. You also clearly must be employed by the industry or have family/friends that is/are. As where of course I've already admitted there's another side to the fence and I know there is, at this point in my life I call it GREED though. I'm sorry my father taught me to WORK for a living, and so I do. I don't try to capitalize on SOFTware <.<
Oh and BTW, if you wanted to get "PERSONAL" ~ Yes, I'm a pirate, but I'll tell you what, previously you've just pretty much ASSUMED that (as I've never directly came out and stated that until now) {so you also REALLY NEED to STOP ASSUMING things too}. However I don't use it like some 10 year old to circumvent paying for it (again it's NOT "STEALING") or however you initially put it. I use it more as a previewing system (also just further backing up my point, and the point of Wucas and others)... I PREVIEW the software FIRST. If I don't like I delete it. If I like it I DO buy it (if it's not some crazy STUPID price like $320 for a legal copy of W7)... The ONLY time I don't pay or buy a "legal copy' yet keep the software is when the company is clearly too GREEDY (like W7/Microsoft)... So I couldn't possibly agree MORE that piracy numbers are WAY off to start with. Here, I'll give a specific example: It was one of those "the sims" games, wasn't even on store shelves yet. I DL'd it, played it like it. Ended up buying it, but wait - surely I'm 1 of the digits in their "statistic" of how many people bootlegged it right, stupid because I'm not, well, I was, but that was to test it, then I ended up buying it -- so was I a lost sale. NO...
On another note, the TRUE 'creators' of SOFTware (for big companies) don't own it. The real life people that write "Windows" or "The Sims" or "Photoshop" guess what, they DO NOT OWN IT. I'm wondering if you even knew that. That IS true, that IS fact -- you can ask anyone in the professional software development industry. They write it for their JOB, so guess who owns it. That's right, the COMPANY that employs them to write it... I can pretty safely assert that some of the very people behind making this software, make pretty piddly salaries compared to the MILLIONS the companies pull in on it's sales... Yet, they're not the ones complaining - they may make just enough money to live their life paycheck to paycheck, but like most NORMAL (not greedy) people - that's 'good enough'. They sit in an office (perhaps even making minimum wage for all you know) writing software for a company. The COMPANY'S are the ones that are complaining if they make 1,000,000 instead of 2,000,000... The company's execs are the ones living in huge houses driving nice cars, not the poor sap who actually helped compose the bajillion lines of code to make their software...
Another thing is I'd LOVE to see your computer(s), you're telling me you have NO pirated software at all whatsoever? You have legit licenses for everything? You have obeyed ALL EULA's/TOS's (IE not installed a copy of something you bought on more than one computer). I somehow doubt that since the only 'people' that truly have to abide by this are companies. Wait, that just furthermore proves my point, why in the hell would I not only spend $320 but $320 PER computer that I own to put W7 on it, that's 10x ridiculous as the price to even buy it ONCE! Again, just typical corporate GREED!
Don't even bother responding to this, I wont be reviewing this thread any longer as the naive people in it are going to drive me to drink... Also, don't go all nancy boy on me and "OMGZ I'm offended", or just argue back, which so far is all you've been able to do (saying pretty much the same thing over and over again despite the fact that we keep bringing up new points to counter your few moot points). Spouting your personally biased OPINIONS as FACTS, which you should not do by the way. If anything I'm hoping - for your own sake - one day you open your mind. If not, maybe some day you can let me know how building that one sided fence in your back yard went...
If anything else Wucas is more correct than either one of us, talking about all the grey areas, and it's much more complex than being plain cut in either of our directions...!