Tell me how I did

[Symbolic.]

I am messing around with photoshop more and was wondering what you guys thought of these two sigs (same but different effects):

Any criticism or applause is appreciated.

 

[fallenfate]

They just look like Cinema4D renders with a character render and bad text choices, to be honest. I recommend looking through DeviantArt for some signature tutorials, .

 

[Symbolic.]

Just updated my signature, CC on that too please :3

 

[fallenfate]

Better than the others, but I think more colour variety, less brightness and more colour depth would be nice. Also if it were a bit smaller, like 450x120, it would be less 'in the face'.

 

[branteh]

The colors to me don't blend very well. I think you have a good concept, but it needs to be easier to look at in my opinion. As for your signature, I think it's better, but it just looks way too bright.

Good job none the less though

 

[ChewBecca]

Imo the first one is better, but the text is horrible, and badly placed.

 

[iamgurb]

Keep trying, your colours are all over the place and there is no balance that appeals to my eyes.