Welcome!

Join our community of MMO enthusiasts and game developers! By registering, you'll gain access to discussions on the latest developments in MMO server files and collaborate with like-minded individuals. Join us today and unlock the potential of MMO server development!

Join Today!

[GOTF] Manga Voting!

Vote


  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Custom Title Activated
Loyal Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2005
Messages
6,598
Reaction score
5,565
Rules

Do not vote for yourself
Do not vote for others
I can not vote, I know who the entrants are
You may NOT reveal which entry is yours until AFTER the voting


If any of the rules are broken, then that person will be disqualified.


Entrants

Wucas
iamgurb



Good Luck, voting will end in 7 days.
 
2D > 3D
Loyal Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
2,413
Reaction score
1,193
Last edited:
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Messages
2,639
Reaction score
945
Meh, can't say much about number 1 since its just a pic of a face.. the other one is atleast creative.


Good job guise.

Your post shows how unskilled you are

#1 Entry:

Gradients
c4ds
Filters
blending
placement

#2 Entry:

3 boxes
2images inside of 2 boxes and 1 out
text added

Now tell me, where do you see creativity on the 2nd one? (No offense to the #2 entry but this kind of contests in my opinion must earn valid feedbacks and viable posts/votes)
 
Custom Title Activated
Loyal Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2005
Messages
6,598
Reaction score
5,565
Your post shows how unskilled you are

#1 Entry:

Gradients
c4ds
Filters
blending
placement

#2 Entry:

3 boxes
2images inside of 2 boxes and 1 out
text added

Now tell me, where do you see creativity on the 2nd one? (No offense to the #2 entry but this kind of contests in my opinion must earn valid feedbacks and viable posts/votes)

The creativeness is probably from the fact that he drew it himself?
 
Mythic Archon
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
700
Reaction score
503
Votes were equal; now that I've voted, Wucas is in the lead.
Good luck to both entrants.
 
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Messages
2,639
Reaction score
945
The creativeness is probably from the fact that he drew it himself?

I cant tell that he drew the character or not, Saying the entry nº1 is just a face is like saying that RZ is just another vbulletin forum (by saying this, I mean that the entry is just a stock and effort was not put into it)

Votes were equal; now that I've voted, Wucas is in the lead.
Good luck to both entrants.

Why you had to unmask the entrants? :junglejane:
 
Joined
Feb 18, 2012
Messages
779
Reaction score
247
Your post shows how unskilled you are

#1 Entry:

Gradients
c4ds
Filters
blending
placement

#2 Entry:

3 boxes
2images inside of 2 boxes and 1 out
text added

Now tell me, where do you see creativity on the 2nd one? (No offense to the #2 entry but this kind of contests in my opinion must earn valid feedbacks and viable posts/votes)

Unskilled? my opinion on art doesn't determine my skill :p:

Also, your not judging how they made it but the outcome. I personally like the second one because the text / way its done.,

Does that explain it to you? :p

Also becca is right to, i can tell that the first one is just a face from some anime with textures and styling on top. The other one I haven't seen so atleast he either took the time to draw it or atleast find something original. :):
 
2D > 3D
Loyal Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
2,413
Reaction score
1,193
Not even 2 days and the names are already out in the open lol.
(Not that it would be hard to tell who made it, but still, kinda takes the fun out of it, o well.)

I'm sorry if my design does not live up to expectation, I just never think of complex c4ds and detailed lighting techniques when I think of Anime and Manga; I think of simplicity. The appeal of the Japanese art style (for me) is how much you can achieve with some simple lines and a very small color palette, and for this reason, I applied the same simplicity in my piece here (and yes, the render is my character design).
 

Dec

Experienced Elementalist
Joined
Aug 21, 2012
Messages
214
Reaction score
147
## Did not realize people could see who I voted for, hence would have ruined who's was who's, merh, already out anyway
 
Last edited:
Custom Title Activated
Loyal Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2005
Messages
6,598
Reaction score
5,565
repost:

Gurb won! Please contact me gurb!

Well done to Wucas if I could vote I would have actually voted for your entry, I liked the originality of it. Will start the second comp soon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top