My vote goes for Entry
#2 for the following reasons:
Entry #1
+ Border is over sized;
+ In terms of Lightning/colors the tag is a mess even though the background fits well with the color of the render's skin, again the colors are messed due to the light(The belt is burning my eyes);
+ text well placed, imo that's the only one and the best place possible for the entry since there is nothing else around the render but the c4d effect behind;
+ Render well placed;
+ Good work with the flow, since the light source of the render is coming from the bottom right of the tag he used the c4d effect to make the flow more visible;
+ Overall the tag is empty in the corners + his right arm looks smudged, a duplication of the render would be better in this situation;
+ The color of his pants are also messed up due to excessive light;
+ There's a huge lightning difference between the render and the c4d effect;
The problem with the TAG itself is the excessive lightning.
Entry #2
+ Good lightning;
+ Good Depth;
+ The Lightning Source is somehow tricky (the light is going to the face and to the chest arms but we can see small lights above her hair meaning that there is light above her head. Overall the lightning is great!);
+ The text placements is kinda meh, too far from the focal and the "3" is barely visible but it blends well with the rest of the tag;
+ The blending is ok, It seems kinda weird on the head since she's lying somewhere and there's no c4d to support her body;