[Voting] Clysse vs lumpydonuts

[lumpydonuts]

Vote for your favorite! You can only vote once, first with 10 votes wins

Clysse:

lumpydonuts:

 

[Secret.]

Theyre both good, but i say Clysse :3

 

[iamgurb]

lumpmydonuts, i think its more clean and i love that light source ;P

 

[Slati93]

yea they are nice, but my vote goes for lumpydonuts cause his sig's quality much better, clysse's sig blurred.

 

[Irahnik]

Personally I don't like either of these... but if I'd have to choose, I'd choose lumpy's.

 

[Clysse]

Personally I don't like either of these... but if I'd have to choose, I'd choose lumpy's.

you never like anything do you

 

[random idiot]

First one would be good, if that thing under the text removed, also if it was sharped a bit.

Second one not much to say about it...but the background is horrible.
meh my vote goes to second one.

 

[Irahnik]

you never like anything do you

Stop crying. You don't even know me, don't judge me.

--Edit, that was mean, my bad. I take that back.

I never said I didn't like ANY of your work. Just... these.

 

[Elian]

Hmm, I do not like the first one for sure, because of the random strip under the text and the low quality.

The second one is err, to easy I think and the lightsource is kinda gay.

I'd have to go with the second one. Even tho the techniques in the first one are better, I just like the outcome of the second one more.

5vs1 so far, if my counting doesnt fail O.O''

 

[lumpydonuts]

Hmm, I do not like the first one for sure, because of the random strip under the text and the low quality.

I kinda like the 'random strip'

 

[Evil[]Power]

lumpydonuts since clysse's one is missing quality im sorry

 

[Irahnik]

Hmm, I do not like the first one for sure, because of the random strip under the text and the low quality.

The second one is err, to easy I think and the lightsource is kinda gay.

I'd have to go with the second one. Even tho the techniques in the first one are better, I just like the outcome of the second one more.

5vs1 so far, if my counting doesnt fail O.O''

It's a "clipping mask of the focal." I don't see how it's related to the picture at all imo.

 

[GzCaptain]

I vote for lumpy.

 

[Pews]

lumpydonuts

 

[EliteGM]

i vote for lumpy

 

[El Jamie]

I vote lumpydonuts, doesn't lack quality and the light source is immense.
No offence, Clysse.

 

[lumpydonuts]

Gg :]

 

[Papercup]

I like lumpydonuts one, Looks more clean -.-

 

[Jawarisin]

lumpy is sharper, but in the context of Halo, Clysse did good.

->Lumpy

 

[Scratch]

Clysse:
the blur style is nice but is blured alooot
the light source is weird, atleast in my monitor i see it like a gif low quality ( looks like dust )
the c4d will fit if u used another mode
the render fits well in the background and the typo is quite nice.
I like the position of the clipping mask you did, the stripe bellow the typo


lumpydonuts,
soft and clean, i like that style as well, and my vote goes to you because im a fan of that kind of style. But. its not really fair to make a fight with different content.
But yeah, the light source is very well placed,i think u gave the render a bit of sharpen, the only thing missing is a good typo and it will be perfect.

Final Vote as already mentioned: lumpydonuts