The chat logs look faked.
[1/18/13 10:41:49 PM] Confused Turtle :3: qq
[1/18/13 10:41:49 PM] Confused Turtle :3: will pay you back on the 25th
So you're telling me he typed all of that within the same second? If this were true, Sublime types over 350 words per minute. The world typing record isn't even over 200 words per minute. Even if skype lags, poop doesn't come through in the same second. The time messages come through depend on the time on the computer or device of the person who sends them. This is why messages on Skype appear further up the chat history sometimes when people are using a mobile network to chat. The time skew makes messages show up above older messages, but the seconds are still counted correctly.
This is no the only instance this happens either. I suggest information like this gets further reviewed in the future before making a decision like permanently banning someone.
I mean, what proof does he have? A dump of faked Skype logs? Dan, really? Sure, he might not have a perfect history, but this thread doesn't present any evidence worthy of a ban.
Edit-
btw, @ your talks about calling Paypal regarding this... LOL. Paypal doesn't handle this stuff over the phone, sorry. Anyone who uses Paypal knows this, so I'm not sure why you're spouting that BS.