[# 1]Your criticism of my work

Results 1 to 9 of 9
  1. #1
    Newbie xBloody is offline
    MemberRank
    Mar 2012 Join Date
    1Posts

    note [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Dear Community,
    This time I want to introduce my two plants.
    I wanted to hear your criticism of this time profile picture and signature.

    Signature:


    Profile Picture:


    Thanks.


  2. #2
    Selfish Bastard Z1ls is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Aug 2009 Join Date
    WinlandLocation
    2,048Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Looks nice in my opinion, nice borders and nice overall, gj :P

  3. #3
    Flyff Developer Intelligence is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2011 Join Date
    United KingdomLocation
    1,401Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Quote Originally Posted by Z1ls View Post
    Looks nice in my opinion, nice borders and nice overall, gj :P

    Yeah agree with this, everything looks nice :D

  4. #4
    PENTAKILL Scratch is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2008 Join Date
    LiverpoolLocation
    3,171Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Bloody Designs + a Butterfly render = nonsense
    Border doesn't look that great I would remove it, the tag would look 10 times better.
    Rainbow background is not really helping
    typo is not working because of your colorful background
    those 2 gray lines being used as a border to the typo were unnecessarily

  5. #5
    ♥ me, I'm an Artist. Slati93 is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Jul 2010 Join Date
    HungaryLocation
    583Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    40% of the sig is a text :S I think thats looks bad.
    and those rainbow lines uhm..

    well.. border and text are like the same "theme".. doesn't fit the tag's theme.. I would use that typo for logo/wallpaper/DVD cover etc..
    the rainbow theme would fit with the butterfly but by that way how you did it isn't beneficial... if you would use that rainbow colours as gradient map I think that would look much better :)

    ps: that typo looks similar to Star Wars typo /ridicule

  6. #6
    Grand Master George SS is offline
    LegendRank
    Oct 2005 Join Date
    3,278Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Why is everyone over using drop shadows in photoshop? Did anyone tell you they are useless , and nobody uses them on default settings? It looks ugly.

  7. #7
    PENTAKILL Scratch is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2008 Join Date
    LiverpoolLocation
    3,171Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Quote Originally Posted by kutsumo View Post
    Why is everyone over using drop shadows in photoshop? Did anyone tell you they are useless , and nobody uses them on default settings? It looks ugly.
    actually drops shadow is very useful, i can get awesome results from that if used properly

  8. #8
    Numero uno tagger. Tiretism is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Dec 2010 Join Date
    512Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    As scratch mentioned above, it the name doesn't match with the butterfly stock. It looks really lq and has a transparent feel to it, work on the saturation, it looks over saturated and lq. The " B " and " D " look squished at top and bottom. Work on your borders. keep practicing.

  9. #9
    Grand Master George SS is offline
    LegendRank
    Oct 2005 Join Date
    3,278Posts

    Re: [# 1]Your criticism of my work

    Quote Originally Posted by Scratch. View Post
    actually drops shadow is very useful, i can get awesome results from that if used properly
    That's right. Unfortunately most of them do not use it properly xD



Advertisement