first sig in a while Constructive criticism appreciated!

[Longitude]

V1
V2

[MentaL]

[404]

Would look better with border. I do have to say that render doesn't blend in ;/ Weird pixilated background. Right half of the signature, doesn't look to bad, but the other half, needs a big improvement.

[Longitude]

It has a very subtle border actually if u look on the right side

[Torched]

Some parts of the background is pixelated, the red c4d things don't really blend well.

[Pews]

I like it.

[AkaInRed]

Messy piece of work with almost no logic/sense to it at all.
It looks a lot as though you took two stocks and pasted one on top of the other.

Colour choices are a little off-contrast.

And 404 is right, it needs border.
If you're not sure what a border is...google.

If what you meant by a 'subtle' border is that thin piece of overlay...
...its so invisible, its no longer defined as a border.
I'm serious, its hardly visible at first. It almost seems to be part of the background.

[Sparrow]

I know nothing about Photoshop, so to me that looks alright...

[ChewBecca]

i think it would be better if the colours were different?
im not too sure, i think its one of those peice i dont like, not because its terrible, just because of my taste.

try changing the colours and getting rid of that random thing on the right.

[Longitude]

ok i took all of your guys'advice

[Irahnik]

colors don't blend, and the brushes are a pain in the eye.

[Torched]

The 2nd one isn't any better IMO. It is too messy.

[Dylan3000]

Stretched render=no-no

[AkaInRed]

What stretched render?


Anyways, the 2nd one doesn't help very much.
RYGB filter + the strange white bits make it look very...off.

[Dylan3000]

Looks stretched to me.