First Signature. Criticism?

[George SS]

Demon puppy or whatever its , was drawn and owned by me , rest is random brushes from DeviantART + my handwriting.

[MentaL]

[tidie10]

Hehe looks like a funny signature, love it :)

[Crapulz]

7/10 :)

[Scratch]

First try? great.

I like to see that you used a pattern board, i really like them tbh
the font was well chosen since the tag is kind of cartoon-like and the font is also related with that (fancy curves etc)

You should place your nick anywhere else not far of the focal.

[AvengerXII]

Great work! Never seen that kind of border o.o.. You should try and enter the "cute monsters" comp that DeviantArt is hosting.

[George SS]

I actually did , but my shirts only had 100 views , and absolutely no votes , so I gave up. There are more talented people than me. Also they have a pen or stylus , I used my Logitech mouse xD

And that border ... is pattern border. Pretty easy to achieve in photoshop , yet people seem to forget or being lazy to use it.

[Fernande]

This is great for your first try! Nothing bad to say about it at all. :)

[Elian]

Great for a first time i gues... (remembering my first time.. such a shame)
Just keep on practising and look up some tutorials. I do not like the border in this signature and the text on the left top.