rate animated my siggy

[Pieman]

hi guys here is my animated siggy what do u guys think of it?



EDIT:for some reason the animation doesnt show up, here is the link to img shack
http://img270.imageshack.us/img270/4...eknight6mk.gif

[MentaL]

[Ramuthra]

works fine for me on here. i got one problem with it. the shiny sword starts way to early on the sword. it includes the handle when was the last time a sword had a shiny handle. in fact i really only see one bit of metal.

[darranthegreat]

the render is deformed! ahhh!
and the shiny sword thing is very cliche =p
anyways, it's still an ok job =)

[RsX]

One of the biggest mistakes you could make while creating a sig is using an image and scaling it without holding shift. If you have to, cut the bottom part of the image off but always have the width and height linked! No matter what.

[tripp1993]

the render is very deformed. :P
the background is pretty cool and the text is fine. overall a 6/10. fix the render and it would probably be 8/10

[fream12]

nice animated sigg
7/10

[InTrO]

nice sig , but i dont like animation on text

[Figa12]

i like the sig, but not the animation

[Necrosis]

one word of advice to u, have a change in style for sigs from what ive been seing from u it all looks the same, same style sig... grungish and well, its weird for me, looks ok but weird to me... experiment eith differenct styles of sigs, as for the animation... i say... the text bit is ok i guess the sword terrible, the only time i would ever do an animated sword would be if it was clearly seen and was clear metal, steal alloy watever not that... thats got like a paint over it that gets rid of the metal look, so i suggest u think about what u are doing and what u need animated, try different approches never take the first, choose wisely on what would look good as an animation plan it out do many tests. ok well thats bout it.... look up flash tutorials and see how that did shit, then try and incorperate it into image ready, works wondors.

[Pieman]

well yeah your right necrosis about the thing i have to change styles (i am experimenting with abstact atm)
but do the animations suck that hard?:confused: