Rate my Sigs!

[criant]

Sig 1


Sig 2


Sig 3


*Note*I did not draw the girl in the second picture. I give props out to the person who did. The rest of the picture is made by me, also the top one was completely made by me.

Which siggy is the best? You tell me!

These sigs were made from scratch! Also vote Yes or No to whether or not you like them, please post any helpful criticizm that might help me. Thanks!

[MentaL]

[AlLoCuRa]

Ill cast my vote for nº2


WTF
Edit:
nº3 is 1337
Change my vote to 3

[JHawk]

whoa tuff there all great there plain but i like plain :D

i vote number 1 i dunno y but i just love it ;)

[Destine]

i vot for 2 =P the thing that attracts me is the person in the middle..

[OutKaster]

can't really vote for a signature.. because that isn't really an signature... they are HUGE, change the size please...
they are beginner "Signatures" the background don't have much effect, the text don't have effect at all and you made the moon? :O

another thing explain me what it means the text in your signatures, since you ahve 2 texts in it ;)

I liked the "Signature" 2, nice colors wierd and funny picure... but i think you have to work on your text effects and put a border in your signature too ;)

I give: 1/10 in the 1st(basicly its Cloud effect with a moon in it :P )
4/10 in 2nd
2/10 in 3rd

[Konrow]

i realy like them. all u have to change is: the moon stand out a little too much, blend it in a little and then add borders

[criant]

well yeah of course i'm gonna shrink them down .. this is just like this for now for the detail

[Valix]

The second sig is to big, messes with the table so don't going to give comments on that :P

fore the first:
1.the bg's just ->render filter clouds, more clouds.
2.text is very plain
3.the moon is nice

for the third:
1.render is cutted out badly/placed badly
2.text is very plain
3.no border or if there is very hard to see
4.bg is way to plain :)