Poll: Well?

Recorded or Live

Results 1 to 23 of 23
  1. #1
    Grand Master JSSnahoG is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Nov 2005 Join Date
    The NetherlandsLocation
    808Posts

    Recorded or Live

    I'm wondering what you prefer, the recorded music, the music that was made in a studio for hours trying to get it right, or live.

    Personally i prefer live, just sounds better (unless the band sucks ofcourse)


  2. #2
    Grand Master Iron Maiden is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    May 2005 Join Date
    Dallas, TexasLocation
    3,748Posts
    Live always sounds better. Unless of course, as JSSnahoG pointed out, the band sucks. Live shows determine what band is really made of because if they can't play a kick ass show, I'm not gonna listen to them.

  3. #3
    Grand Master DeXtEr_gr is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2005 Join Date
    guarding low bapLocation
    514Posts
    live of courseeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :P everyone of us selected live lol

  4. #4
    Grand Master Mick is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Apr 2003 Join Date
    ScotlandLocation
    832Posts
    Aye live, love the sound of live gigs

  5. #5
    Grand Master Obbob is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Feb 2005 Join Date
    Behind You!Location
    2,626Posts
    Live :D

  6. #6
    Me > You DaCheat is offline
    LegendRank
    May 2004 Join Date
    Minneapolis, MNLocation
    7,263Posts
    its gotta be live...unless the band REALLY sucks...

    besides..you dont see people moshing to a CD do ya???? NO! lol

  7. #7
    Grand Master DeXtEr_gr is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2005 Join Date
    guarding low bapLocation
    514Posts
    *But live in a video OR live at concert????*

  8. #8
    Captain of the Universe Rishwin is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Oct 2004 Join Date
    PerthLocation
    15,097Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by DaCheat
    besides..you dont see people moshing to a CD do ya???? NO! lol
    i do :(

    and yea, live ftw ^^

  9. #9
    Elite Member DarkestHour is offline
    Member +Rank
    Feb 2006 Join Date
    In the center of a Cannible Corpse moshpit.Location
    186Posts
    It just simply depends on what band your talking about.

    For example: Ive seen Motorhead live a couple of times. And i must say, live is much better; especailly Ace Of Spades. Or a Brutal Death Metal band like All Shall Perish is increadible live.

    But then there are bands that are simply not as good live. Like Trivium. They are an awsome band, their even good live. But their albums are much better then their concerts. (Although i cant resist the mosh pits)

    So it all depends on the band.

  10. #10
    Grand Master JSSnahoG is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Nov 2005 Join Date
    The NetherlandsLocation
    808Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by DeXtEr_gr
    *But live in a video OR live at concert????*
    Both, poll is really about the sound, not the expierence, otherwise you can't compare it at all.

  11. #11
    Johnny RsX is offline
    LegendRank
    May 2004 Join Date
    MiamiLocation
    5,042Posts
    I prefer recorded. When its recorded, the sound is perfect. Theres no yelling and screaming in the bg, theres no echoes, etc.

    When its recorded, its clear, perfect, etc.


    I dont listen to music to study the band u idiots :P I listen to music in order to e-n-j-o-y it. If i wanted to test a bands skill i would listen to live music.

  12. #12
    hi Kaoii is offline
    LegendRank
    Nov 2003 Join Date
    5,853Posts
    live because you dont have to work out more than two guitars to tab a song (Def Leppard's Hysteria studio recording had nine guitars!).

  13. #13
    Grand Master Iron Maiden is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    May 2005 Join Date
    Dallas, TexasLocation
    3,748Posts
    One of the best live shows I've been to was last night at the Coldplay concert.

  14. #14
    Grand Master GOD is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Sep 2005 Join Date
    2,222Posts
    Recorded in studio is the best..live just sounds like crap

  15. #15
    Grand Master Obbob is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Feb 2005 Join Date
    Behind You!Location
    2,626Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Nefilim
    Recorded in studio is the best..live just sounds like crap
    Live is so much better ;)

  16. #16
    Grand Master Iron Maiden is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    May 2005 Join Date
    Dallas, TexasLocation
    3,748Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Obbob
    Live is so much better ;)
    I agree.

  17. #17
    hi Kaoii is offline
    LegendRank
    Nov 2003 Join Date
    5,853Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Nefilim
    Recorded in studio is the best..live just sounds like crap
    you mean the band you were listening to was crap?
    if a band is so bad that they have to go to a studio to get help playing their own songs and when their playing live you have to go halfway through a song to recognize it, then theres a problem.

    i dont listen to music just to enjoy it, i listen to it to see how good the band actually is, what the guitars are doing, and what the vocalist is doing.

  18. #18
    Grand Master Obbob is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Feb 2005 Join Date
    Behind You!Location
    2,626Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Kaoii
    you mean the band you were listening to was crap?
    if a band is so bad that they have to go to a studio to get help playing their own songs and when their playing live you have to go halfway through a song to recognize it, then theres a problem.

    i dont listen to music just to enjoy it, i listen to it to see how good the band actually is, what the guitars are doing, and what the vocalist is doing.
    Kaoii got the right spirit for music ;D

  19. #19
    Grand Master GOD is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Sep 2005 Join Date
    2,222Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Obbob
    Live is so much better ;)
    Yea if your def, lol

  20. #20
    Grand Master Obbob is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Feb 2005 Join Date
    Behind You!Location
    2,626Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Nefilim
    Yea if your def, lol
    Ive rather listen to live than recorded.
    Recorded sounds so gay when the singer goes like AHHHH and you still hear it when he sings another thing.

  21. #21
    Grand Master GOD is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Sep 2005 Join Date
    2,222Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Obbob
    Ive rather listen to live than recorded.
    Recorded sounds so gay when the singer goes like AHHHH and you still hear it when he sings another thing.
    well, we all have our own opinions

  22. #22
    Grand Master Obbob is offline
    Grand MasterRank
    Feb 2005 Join Date
    Behind You!Location
    2,626Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Nefilim
    well, we all have our own opinions
    Yep ;)

  23. #23
    Member yeah is offline
    MemberRank
    Feb 2006 Join Date
    95Posts
    im missing that "i love live music " gene. Ppl finally gave up on me lol and stopped asking me to go to concerts. Ive been to a lot and been asked to a lot. My ex works for the second largest lighting company in the world. Did lights for so many bands, big bands..and most of the time i got backstage passes..but STILL just wasnt my scene! lol! Friends would be like "wtf is WRONG with u!" hahahhaha. All that yelling..and sweaty lights..and groping..and stinky black out curtain ..and geez list could go on. Just gmme a NON life mp3 and lemme chill out. XD



Advertisement