Rock band or Guitar Hero?

[theninjaway]

Which one should I get?

[MentaL]

[Wilsongb1010]

GH3 for the Wii

[DaOdin]

Both suck shit.

[theninjaway]

Both suck shit.

I beg to differ.

[Mreow]

No competition, rock band.

[RastaLulz]

I'd have to say, Guitar Hero.

[theninjaway]

I'd have to say, Guitar Hero.

I ordered guitar hero, as Rock Band looks like a spin-off.

[Vendaku~Metal]

Guitar Hero 4 will DESTROY Rockband.

But anyways, GH3 right now is a lot of fun.

[theninjaway]

Guitar Hero 4 will DESTROY Rockband.

But anyways, GH3 right now is a lot of fun.

How good is the Guitar controller, Trav?

[sutsurikeru]

GH 3 All the way, the controller is very robust and plays well

[alexdesire]

Rock band looks so much better than GH but ive actually never played Rock band or GH

[ChewBecca]

rock band looks good just from the point of the drum pad
but ive only played guitar hero, and that is very good :)

[MentaL]

for guitar, hero is the way to go, but theres a new gh out soon with drums and what not which should surpass rockband overall, and imo rockband is terrible.

[xblackcat]

Hmm Guitar heros is better overall, but its funnier to play rock band with friends

[Unleashed Hell]

Shouldn't this topic be in Gaming Hotspot? :P

[-Austiin]

Well Rockband is better, only because you all work together XD
but the drums brake so easily.

I don't have Rockband though, I have GH3.

[Jack]

I think you should get a dance mat instead

na...

[Jack]

I think you should get a dance mat instead

na...

[ImaMoFoThief]

GH3 for the Wii

very good game own it on wii

Both suck shit.

i beg to differ

No competition, rock band.

i agree with this statement if on 360 or ps3

I ordered guitar hero, as Rock Band looks like a spin-off.

100% not spin off but 100% pure awesomness

Guitar Hero 4 will DESTROY Rockband.



But anyways, GH3 right now is a lot of fun.

yes GH4 will be great but i just want RB2 for pinball wizzard

How good is the Guitar controller, Trav?

at launch it was very very crappy for all consoles

GH 3 All the way, the controller is very robust and plays well

the controller sucks compared to the fender stratocaster

as i own both games for the wii i personally love rockband more b/c of song selection and the guitar... more could of been done with drums tbh... owners of GH:WT are going to break the symbols off in 24hr's of first owning it...

[KyleEnos]

Real guitar.

If 12 year olds spent as much time on GH as they did on a real guitar they'd be a virtuoso in no time.

[altairr]

Guitar hero, DUHHHH.

[Ron]

Depends. Guitar Hero is better for playing alone, though the fun factor is a lot higher for Rock Band because of the multiple instruments. Rock band could use harder songs and better solo sections though.

Real guitar.

If 12 year olds spent as much time on GH as they did on a real guitar they'd be a virtuoso in no time.

qft.

[LightWarrior]

Real guitar.

If 12 year olds spent as much time on GH as they did on a real guitar they'd be a virtuoso in no time.

I was gonna say that, But I promised myself never to post in theninjaway topics......
Just get rockband, better deal...

[Anujan]

RockBand

[Youngy]

Real guitar.

If 12 year olds spent as much time on GH as they did on a real guitar they'd be a virtuoso in no time.

True, but what do 12 year olds find more fun? Playing games or playing instruments?
They'd rather play games over doing a lot of other things lol.