My very first sig

Hi I'm new to RaGEZONE and I made my first sig...

http://img480.imageshack.us/img480/3807/absak6xv.jpg

first:welcome to ragezone :)
your sigg is good 9/10 from me :)

my opinion if u r new to PS , then, 7.5/10
experienced 4/10 :)

the only thing good about that sig is the backgorund.
The render sucks, and is out of shape. And it doesnt fit in at all.
Also try to blend the text in.

3/10

Render stretched, text... dont blend EVERYTHING -_- but some text blending may be good :)

for first one... 7/10

How about my second one?

http://img170.imageshack.us/img170/782/absak0cf.jpg

thats worse...

You're first one was way better, but the first needs render blending

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by K-swiss

thats worse...

---

Excactly...

Don't you guys think you are a little to hard on him.. theres a difference between starting-line critism, and expert critism, this isnt american idol, you can be nicer to him, and for you K-Swiss, your sig isnt much better.. and why don't you guys give him advice, not just put him down.. afterall, you guys are "experts" at this... right?

ye, i'm with Valix

yeah first one looked better but needs work. 8/10 for noobie (no worries im a noob to lol)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by syonyde

Don't you guys think you are a little to hard on him.. theres a difference between starting-line critism, and expert critism, this isnt american idol, you can be nicer to him, and for you K-Swiss, your sig isnt much better.. and why don't you guys give him advice, not just put him down.. afterall, you guys are "experts" at this... right?

---

Yeap, people do judge here way to hard.... nice 1st sig 8/10 the second one wasnt as good 7/10

the first one is better, for a beginner its a good sig.. i give you 7.5/10
second one: 2/10

Um I just finished this and I could use some reccomendations on the text effects.

http://img23.imageshack.us/img23/8169/absak0zp.jpg