[Compulsory: READ] Comments

I've got some PM's about how people give their opinions on stuff they make, for an example.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Signature maker

Made this sig cause i were so bored!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Replies

It's too dark

---

Now, i know i myself do this sometimes cause im too lazy to explain every part i do or do not like. If some guy make his signature and really like it, no comment here can change that, that's why i really never bother posting more than my "basic thought" about it. This is one of some PM's i've got.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Evil_Forest

I've been using Ragezone gfx forum for a little while now, I've noticed that no one on this forum actually helps each other, only critisises each other. How can anyone improve on thier previous signature if all they get told is

"text looks crap, the left is dark, the border looks crap"

I am told that mine look good or bad, fair enough, but they dont say why or how in thier eyes I can improve.

That may be how your forum operates, but If i were you, I'd ask the people that comment to actually make a decent comment and help someone improve.

Theres my 22 pence.

---

If you DO agree with Evil_Forest, say so. Cause if more than half of the people say YES, i will set rules for how you should, and should not comment on things.

If there are any users that have an opinion on how the rules should be set, and how strict they should be. Feel free to PM me, and i'll reply to them asap.


// Flawz

i dont agree.

if you are posting your signature, that means YOU ARE HAPPY WITH WHAT YOU HAVE DONE. If this is not the case, then dont fucking post it untill you are.

so if you are happy with it, you do infact NEED people to tell you which parts need improving, because as far as you are cocirned, there is nothing wrong with it. you DO NOT need us to tell you HOW to improve thoes aspects (even though most of the time we do advise you), because if you cannot see that for yourself then nobody can help you.

eg. as with the "too dark" comment, HOW do you want him to post it then? Do you want the person to type "too dark, make it lighter"? if you cannot figgure out by yourself that something needs to be made lighter if its too dark, then your a fucktard and dont deserve to be in the internet.

yeah, some people comment like that. and its preetty annoying. but it doesn't matter if you set up rules, it wouldn't change. people are too damn lazy to read stickies anymore

(my opinion thread got 60 views in 2 weeks)

I tried to deal with this when I was a mod here, it's no use ...
But in the end you can't blame all of them, this still is a mmorpg forum ...

Those with true designer blood will give constructive comments, that's still why those become well known and the others saying: I don't like it will not

I appreciate all your well comments, thank you alot people, and as it looks right now; You comment the way you like, if you decide to give MORE constructive comments, do so. It's all up to you.

wow, valix is back, nice to see you back dude!! hope we can see some of your work back in action... anywho i do agree and some what disagree, its the persons right to say what they feel about the sig/artwork, and if they say something bad, some else may feel the same way about it will second that opinion if they dont, its always up to the designer that should ask as to why they said it, not flaming them but politely ask, however it is also a pain staking moment to see something like that written about your work and therefore you end up getting a bit bitchy... anywho, im neutral on this matter i guess.