Shinn

http://i211.photobucket.com/albums/b...ners/Shinn.png

Credits to Daodin for cutting the render for me =]

Too simple of a foreground. The render seems low quality, and the pen tooling doesn't flow well with the image

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rainwizzard

Too simple of a foreground. The render seems low quality, and the pen tooling doesn't flow well with the image

---

There no pen tooling and thanks for CC ^^

The images was good quality i probably added to much depth ill lower the opacity of my high pass layer

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FullMetalKite

There no pen tooling and thanks for CC ^^

The images was good quality i probably added to much depth ill lower the opacity of my high pass layer

---

if it isn't pen tooling, it it just C4Ds around the render?

Yeah with differant effects

Wave ripple etc.

Drop shadows :(

It's okay, I'd say take that wave ripple out, and also the shadow on the text.

@Rain,

I don't get what's up with you and simple. Sometimes the simple, can be the best. If you add to much junk, it can make your signature look bad..

Eh imo thats a pretty wicked sig

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kohaku

@Rain,

I don't get what's up with you and simple. Sometimes the simple, can be the best. If you add to much junk, it can make your signature look bad..

---

I'm sorry graphic master, but I want people to do better, and my way of doing that is to not puss out on stating what seems wrong. You've been away from GFX for a while, i don't expect you to understand.

I say what i believe to be wrong. And here, i find it's too plain. Plain sigs mean 1 of two things, either not enough inspiration, or lack of talent. I know FMK is only lacking inspiration in this peoce because i know HE actually has TALENt with photoshop.

I think the background looks really nice, except for those giant shards sticking up infront of where Shinn is.

I like the sig, thought not to fond of the crystal like C4D at the render.

Keep it up ;)

nice men xD

i kinda like it. cept its shin..................
the crystals make it a bit interesting....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Onnagata

i kinda like it. cept its shin..................
the crystals make it a bit interesting....

---

Shinn Rockz.

Ty for the comments guys ^^

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rainwizzard

I'm sorry graphic master, but I want people to do better, and my way of doing that is to not puss out on stating what seems wrong. You've been away from GFX for a while, i don't expect you to understand.

I say what i believe to be wrong. And here, i find it's too plain. Plain sigs mean 1 of two things, either not enough inspiration, or lack of talent. I know FMK is only lacking inspiration in this peoce because i know HE actually has TALENt with photoshop.

---

It has nothing to do with talent with photoshop, it's talent in art, in general. To have a mind that can put things togethor, and have deeper meaning, but still have the outlook somewhat expressive, or just to be able to think of something that will look nice off the top of your head, and not have to sit and think about it. You have to be able to see something and think "I could transform that into something amazing."

Photoshop...there is no talent with photoshop, there's just knowing how to use it..

And I have noticed in almost all of your comments, you've been leaving "Not enough effects" or "too plain"..

And tbh when I look at some of your work I see little or no work done...And you rely too much on one thing at a time instead of adding multiple techniques..

I have nothing against you, I've just noticed it and for some reason It's been bugging me that you've been downing all signatures with the same exact comments, and honestly you're no senior to the Portfolio section so I don't get what you mean by he's been away for a while and he wouldn't understand.


Sorry, just had to get that off my chest, it's just been bugging me and I don't want to let it turn into some kind of hatred for you for no reason really.


Anyway, I like the signature, all except for the filtered C4D to the right it seems to flow well.

7/10.

Keep up the good work, I like the diversity in your signatures.