Printable View
alright i want you guyes to treat this as if you never played GH or RB b4... no mentioning past controllers, no past experience's with the games...
Just the new peripherals how you think they will work, the setlist and the features...
i personally put my money on Gh:wt b/c of the create a rocker and mii use, the confirmed Dlc for wii, and most of the songs...
Rb2 is close b/c of the really good songs but its not innovative enough from Rb1.... no clue if wii has Dlc or not...
I'm for Rock Band 2.
Reasons:
1. Its supposed to Have 500 songs. GH won't have that many.
2. If you get bored with the guitar, you can play the drums, or sing.
3. Rock Bands New Drum Set has a better set up than the GH 4 drum set.
4. Rock Band is more fun when you play multiplayer.
i mentioned the wii specific stuff so Rb's 500 songs are maybe 110 tops atm for wii... new Gh:wt can drum, sing, bass, guitar aswell.... the drum setup is the same as b4 on rb1 you cannot judge multiplayer atm b/c gh:wt is NOT released...Quote:
Originally Posted by demonsmind
I haven't seen anything about GH having a Microphone.
GH4's drum set has 3 drums and 1 symbol (Maybe 2 symbols, cant remember)
RB drum set now comes with 4 drums and 2 symbols. Making it more realistic than GH drum set.
I don't know much about the Wii versions because I haven't checked into it.
I wouldn't have thought they would have been any different.
I have only seen the xbox360, and playstation versions of the new GH4 and RB2, and from what I have seen, RB2 wins.
... the GH site, store, wikipedia list a microphone... they would not jump into drums w/o vocals... yes 3 drums 2 cymbals and a bass peddal there are no symbols yet just 3rd party ones that make the 2-3 of same color to be useless on kit making it cymbals...Quote:
Originally Posted by demonsmind
Wii version should be greatly different... RB1 was a port of the game from ps2 meaning no DLC or online... knowing EA they will just do it again
you have obviously never seen much b/c you would of heard about GHTunes... and if you were to google b4 you posted you would know the drums are same...even if you add 3 symbols to it 3 pads are useless...
GH4 DrumsQuote:
Originally Posted by ImaMoFoThief
RockBand 2 Drums
Drums are not the same, and yes I still use PS2 and I am aware of EA's scam, and I agree that PS2 will remain No DLC. PS2 did not come with a built in hard drive, so of course you won't be able to download new songs to it, unless you installed a HD, and used the 3rd party boot disk, so PS2 will still be screwed out of the dlc.
the RB drums are the same in box... you have to pay extra 300 dollars to get that premium drum kit that can be used as a real electronic drum kitQuote:
Originally Posted by demonsmind
the ones you get in box of RB2 are the same thing as RB1 with some modifications in the pads making them quieter...
with the cymbals they completely override the pads
there is no innovation to the RB just added songs and new visual
the rb2 drums are more realisitic in my opinion and if therer quiter thats gonna be good for late nights
I'm going with RB2 because 1. the DLC is cross game rb/rb2 2. the songs in the marketplace are cheaper. 3. Rock band 2's background feels like you're in a music video. 4. So what if GH4 has cymbals, they're plastic and bound to break fast.
really 500 songs?Quote:
Originally Posted by demonsmind
omgomgomg
im getting rockband 2 then
rockband 2. period.
There will be Downloadable content aswell. i have the GH series as well as Rockband.
and rockband is winning by a LONG SHOT! not just because the other instruments i mean the songs are Awsome! even the guitar play in rockband is better than GH!
so id say Rockband 2. Even my mum likes it and she hates computer games.
Enough said. lol.
rockband 2. period.
There will be Downloadable content aswell. i have the GH series as well as Rockband.
and rockband is winning by a LONG SHOT! not just because the other instruments i mean the songs are Awsome! even the guitar play in rockband is better than GH!
so id say Rockband 2. Even my mum likes it and she hates computer games.
Enough said. lol.
but on a level of no experiance i would have gone for rockband first as its more flashy and looks alot better. i mean even the case looks awsome and when you see the instruments it makes you get excited :)
It has like 80 disc songs + tons of DLCQuote:
Originally Posted by ihatehaxor
the DLC is on a level of it has over i think 480+ songs in the XBL Marketplace? il look it up later. or atleast thats rockband. imagine rockband 2!
Guitar hero should jsut be GUITAR hero.
All RB1 songs have the potential to be on RB2.Quote:
Originally Posted by kaiyx
What... that many songs...Quote:
Originally Posted by ihatehaxor
Guitar Hero 3 barely have songs... around 100 or less....
Gota' kidding me....
I'ma get me some rock band!
+plus Guitar hero's songs are more expensive.Quote:
Originally Posted by ファックするジェイ
Im really not sure.
Only thing that pushes me toward GHWT is the song maker.
Making your own GH tracks. Thats pretty sexy.
But RB has always been my fav. and I already have RB instrument so i'll proly get RB2.
Only becuase of the price. I'm not really that wealthy. =/
i'll be getting Rock Band, Drums appeal to me more then Guitar.
Personally, I want both, but that's not going to happen lol.
You can use the rb1 instruments on GH4, but it changes the charts, so that kinda sucks, cause you probably won't be able to use all the features in the music maker.
The GH4 drum looks really good, and I want that now, as well as keeping the Rock Band 1 drums but I won't have room lol
So, uhm, RB2 'cause of the setlist/amount of songs ...
Do you know people for guitar hero got sued, sence they basicly copyed Rock band with the drums, Mic. But, I like guitar hero way better, they got plenty of new shit. Rockband is just Blah
Yeah, they are kinda copying but they had to so they could keep in competition lol.
All instruments for both games are compatible with both games and the instruments for GH4 look so much better at the moment, I HATE the rockband guitar.
So I'll probs get GH4 for the better instruments and buy rockband 2, just the disc for the songs and so i can get DLC.
Ima have to choose GH world tour because its completly new, Rock band is basicly same as 1st :)
I have to agree with you. I cant wait to start making my own songs :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Retro!