-
Amputation as punishment!
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/11/wo...s.html?_r=1&hp
http://media.novinky.cz/763/337630-gallery1-rbyps.jpg
How cool is that? So you are like accused of stealing food or something, they catch you and cut off your right hand and left leg.
And the best part is, it was the god who ordered to do so, not the police or judges or whoever. Allah ackbar :rolleyes:
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Yeah, it happens in the majority of countries in the middle east/asia, even Turkey do it. That's probably why they're the safest countries, because there's no robbers and places like Saudi Arabia are the richest, because everyone actually pays for stuff!
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Better they need to cut the head, because they don't use it !
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
^ Would be easier to do that. They cut off limbs so they suffer forever more though.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
And what happens if you are innocent and just got accused. ohnoes
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
I'm not sure which country it was (some parts of Saudi iirc) .. they cut your ting-a-ling-ling for adultery. :|
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
I would hate to see what they do to rapists.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Chris
I would hate to see what they do to rapists.
Executed I think, but I bet before that they cut their ting-aling-ling off.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
I'm sure the crime rate will decrease.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Well its not the most humane way to do it is it, also its violating peoples human rights.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Ohnoes paper cut.
Jokes, but this is bad. :dontknow:
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
The first question wouldn't be why do they cut your hand but it would be why would you steal?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Chris
I would hate to see what they do to rapists.
Rapists are executed by throwing rocks at them till death.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jazeon
And what happens if you are innocent and just got accused. ohnoes
Obviously in such harsh rules they would have to catch you stealing to amputate your hand but i don't think so when your framed unless you tell them that you did it.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Repthon
The first question wouldn't be why do they cut your hand but it would be why would you steal?
Rapists are executed by throwing rocks at them till death.
Obviously in such harsh rules they would have to catch you stealing to amputate your hand but i don't think so when your framed unless you tell them that you did it.
There are lots of reasons people steal, no offence but in middle east countries there is a big difference from the rich and the poor. People steal because they don't have enough food to live or can't survive, if you were starving hungry and had no other choice i think you would, sometimes when they steal they are trying to get abit of money or food for they families the government doesn't help them as they do in the UK or other MEDC countries. However there is people who just steal to be rich which is totally wrong and should be punished but not but violating they human rights.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jazeon
And what happens if you are innocent and just got accused. ohnoes
Nothing (well that's how it should be).
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Shoelace
Well its not the most humane way to do it is it, also its violating peoples human rights.
Are you kidding?
I want to clear some stuff:
First, there are people or even countries that don't apply Islam as it's supposed to be.
Second, to cut the hand of a robber there have to be 9 rules according to Islam, but yeah as I said there are people who just do it wrong, bah, I'm Muslim and I'm against of what they are doing, I don't care if they're Muslims or not. (I didn't read the article - however cutting a leg because of stealing, is wrong.)
Please make a research about Islam (right sources) before judging, thanks.
Peace.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
It's a bit of a small minded way to solve a problem. An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
I think the UK aren't harsh enough with criminals, but I don't think resorting to mutilation and capitol punishment is the way forward either.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ezpzzz
Nothing (well that's how it should be).
Are you kidding?
I want to clear some stuff:
First, there are people or even countries that don't apply Islam as it's supposed to be.
Second, to cut the hand of a robber there have to be 9 rules according to Islam, but yeah as I said there are people who just do it wrong, bah, I'm Muslim and I'm against of what they are doing, I don't care if they're Muslims or not. (I didn't read the article - however cutting a leg because of stealing, is wrong.)
Please make a research about Islam (right sources) before judging, thanks.
Peace.
May i ask what this has got to with Islam on what i just said.
" Its not the most humane way to do it " - Well it isn't
" Violating peoples human rights * - As one of the human rights ( Freedom from torture and inhuman or degrading treatment ). Is it inhuman to cut someone's hand off?
I might be wrong.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Disgusting, that's terrible.
Some countries just don't know how to teach people a lesson. Their using the wrong methods. Cutting of things is for sure not right, and is as one of the above posters said, against human rights.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Shoelace
Well its not the most humane way to do it is it, also its violating peoples human rights.
They never heard of human rights.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
nathan123
It's a bit of a small minded way to solve a problem. An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
I think the UK aren't harsh enough with criminals, but I don't think resorting to mutilation and capitol punishment is the way forward either.
Our prisons are like luxury hotels compared to US prisons, Or mexican, My cousin was in prison for a year but got out after 6 months and he said it only taught him about the crimes he committed (Stealing a car, Other minor stuff that mounted up), and the only thing that would stop him from stealing something again is his baby coming... mm no one wants to go to prison but British prisons should be tougher as long as I don't go to prison some point in my life.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Retro!
They never heard of human rights.
They do know about human rights however their government's aren't doing anything about it , there are many charities out there who are trying to change the way countries work and make human rights one of the main things their believe in and everyone have . ( wow your avatar its stopping me from thinking )
Quote:
Originally Posted by
zJordan
Our prisons are like luxury hotels compared to US prisons, Or mexican, My cousin was in prison for a year but got out after 6 months and he said it only taught him about the crimes he committed (Stealing a car, Other minor stuff that mounted up), and the only thing that would stop him from stealing something again is his baby coming... mm no one wants to go to prison but British prisons should be tougher as long as I don't go to prison some point in my life.
I totally agree with this UK prisons are soft and should be much harder, for some people who don't have much a prison for them is a roof over their heads and daily food.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ezpzzz
Nothing (well that's how it should be).
Are you kidding?
I want to clear some stuff:
First, there are people or even countries that don't apply Islam as it's supposed to be.
Second, to cut the hand of a robber there have to be 9 rules according to Islam, but yeah as I said there are people who just do it wrong, bah, I'm Muslim and I'm against of what they are doing, I don't care if they're Muslims or not. (I didn't read the article - however cutting a leg because of stealing, is wrong.)
Please make a research about Islam (right sources) before judging, thanks.
Peace.
Stop talking out of your ass because it is gods rules and if you are not following them then what is the point of being a muslim.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Shoelace
They do know about human rights however their government's aren't doing anything about it , there are many charities out there who are trying to change the way countries work and make human rights one of the main things their believe in and everyone have . ( wow your avatar its stopping me from thinking )
Their government's not doing about it because they don't work that way, nor will it change.
All the charities in the world don't matter.
(Ilovemyavatar)
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Shoelace
There are lots of reasons people steal, no offence but in middle east countries there is a big difference from the rich and the poor. People steal because they don't have enough food to live or can't survive, if you were starving hungry and had no other choice i think you would, sometimes when they steal they are trying to get abit of money or food for they families the government doesn't help them as they do in the UK or other MEDC countries. However there is people who just steal to be rich which is totally wrong and should be punished but not but violating they human rights.
In every country in the world there is difference between rich and poor and you can't disagree because it is a fact.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
The only scenario I'd approve of of mutilating someone are rapists... there's no 'need' to rape someone, unlike someone stealing food needing it to live. Cutting off a person's hand for stealing food is completely unjustifiable.
-
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Repthon
In every country in the world there is difference between rich and poor and you can't disagree because it is a fact.
This is not what I meant for example in the Uk there is rich and poor people however there is like a middle line group who aren't rich or are not poor, in the Uk there isn't many people who are so poor that they can't buy some food to live on however in middle eastern and African counties there it lots of people in poverty who can't buy food or have enough food to live on , also there is very rich people who do have lots of many compared to the people in poverty. I hoped I cleared that up for you and it made sense lol
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Retro!
Their government's not doing about it because they don't work that way, nor will it change.
All the charities in the world don't matter.
(Ilovemyavatar)
If your saying that then why has the UK changed, why do we have equal rights for coloured, why don't we have the death penalty. Everything can change , also charities do alot .
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
islam sucks, so does their god and shit
wish there were no religions
there is no fucking way to justify cutting off the fucking right hand and left leg to some young guys, especially just because some stupid god orders them to do so
just imaging that, right hand, left leg, it's worse then if they cut off both of your legs, it makes you completely incapable of doing anything, and it's not gonna be only your "problem", it's gonna become huge burden for your whole family, I can imagine those people commiting suicide short after this.. religion of peace and love my ass
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
foxx
islam sucks, so does their god and shit
wish there were no religions
there is no fucking way to justify cutting off the fucking right hand and left leg to some young guys, especially just because some stupid god orders them to do so
just imaging that, right hand, left leg, it's worse then if they cut off both of your legs, it makes you completely incapable of doing anything, and it's not gonna be only your "problem", it's gonna become huge burden for your whole family, I can imagine those people commiting suicide short after this.. religion of peace and love my ass
Very true, religions are supposed to be based around peace and avoiding harm and crime, this is just the opposite but tbh is this stoppable?
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Shoelace
This is not what I meant for example in the Uk there is rich and poor people however there is like a middle line group who aren't rich or are not poor, in the Uk there isn't many people who are so poor that they can't buy some food to live on however in middle eastern and African counties there it lots of people in poverty who can't buy food or have enough food to live on , also there is very rich people who do have lots of many compared to the people in poverty. I hoped I cleared that up for you and it made sense lol
Not everyone steals because they can't get food, hell if i didn't have food ill just survive on water and bread rather than stealing.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Repthon
Not everyone steals because they can't get food, hell if i didn't have food ill just survive on water and bread rather than stealing.
I never said everyone steals because they don't have food, also you need proteins and fats too and bread won't do that for you some people don't even have enough money for clean water and bread. You seem so simple minded not everyone has water and bread.
http://zakathouse.files.wordpress.co...pg?w=300&h=203
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Already heard from things like this in some countrys, that's bad, but so is stealing, if you don't want your hand and/or leg being cutted, then just don't steal, it's that simple...
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
let's see.. your family is starving, your younger sister haven't had anything to eat in 3 days, so you go and try to steal an apple for her.. they catch you and cut off your right hand and left leg.. fair, right, because stealing is bad, mkay
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
It's pretty much only Islamic countries with such laws now, and that's because they follow the out-dated set of Sharia laws which have no place in modern society.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Z1ls
Already heard from things like this in some countrys, that's bad, but so is stealing, if you don't want your hand and/or leg being cutted, then just don't steal, it's that simple...
No, it's not "that simple" - simply because people in poverty starving become desperate and steal food to live... as an example.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Depends what country it is, Iraqi Kurdistan has been said to be the best Islamic Country, modern laws and society, and not being forced to be a Muslim...
-
There is just no arguing that, compared to christian/buddhist/hindu/whatever countries, muslim countries are shit. Maybe not all of them, but the general idea I get when I turn on the news is just shit.
Theocracies are just the utter retards of this planet.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
EliteGM
There is just no arguing that, compared to christian/buddhist/hindu/whatever countries, muslim countries are shit. Maybe not all of them, but the general idea I get when I turn on the news is just shit.
Theocracies are just the utter retards of this planet.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
That's because there is still lots of love for the jews. Wait until the jews run out of their WWII pity and watch the news then.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
EliteGM
There is just no arguing that, compared to christian/buddhist/hindu/whatever countries, muslim countries are shit. Maybe not all of them, but the general idea I get when I turn on the news is just shit.
Theocracies are just the utter retards of this planet.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Here comes another guy who just believes the news propaganda. If you see every shit muslim country and look at their history and how they became shit you will find America or Israel 100% included and in some cases also Europe is there.
-
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Repthon
Here comes another guy who just believes the news propaganda. If you see every shit muslim country and look at their history and how they became shit you will find America or Israel 100% included and in some cases also Europe is there.
Why can you not just agree with the fact that setting a fucking embassy on fire and killing an ambassador and his staff because OF A FILM CAN NOT AND WILL NOT HAPPEN IN EUROPE OR THE US CURRENTLY.
Im not saying anything about history because if we were talking 1000 years earlier, the Christians were the bad guys with their crusades and all. Its just right now that these countries show a clear distinction of being fuckups.
Tldr: religion is to blame
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
I never disagreed that setting the embassy on fire was something good, i am 100% against it and will just make the problem worst and worst. This is not even the first time they make fun of prophet mohammed.
Muslims never insulted any religion or made a movie insulting Jesus then why make fun of our prophet? It shows who is looking for trouble here.
-
Re: Amputation as punishment!
Epic Arabs Like Always :P
in my country we don't cut hands ~ Straight heads ^^ xD