[3rd Sig] Critism welcomed ;)

[YouAreNotBob]

Ok, I started Photoshop on friday, ya da ya da, and here it is, my 3rd one. Please tell me which one was the best and what I need to work on.(which I definitely need)

1st SIG:

2nd SIG:

2nd SIG v2

3rd SIG:

EDIT: Oh damn, I forgot to add a border, I'll add it later.

 

[kstor1234]

ok once again the same background...hmmm well the text of the nike blah blah is not nice...either the future is here...

the render of the shoe is good, but it just doesnt look good

6/10 gl with it

 

[YouAreNotBob]

ok once again the same background...hmmm well the text of the nike blah blah is not nice...either the future is here...

the render of the shoe is good, but it just doesnt look good

6/10 gl with it

aw damn, I thought the background was different since I used clouds instead =/. Also I thought the text was OK enough for this type of sig.

Anyways, thanks, I'll try to change the ways I do things in my next sig.

 

[Mreow]

Backgrounds need work, looks like all your renders are squished. 3.5/10

 

[YouAreNotBob]

Backgrounds need work, looks like all your renders are squished. 3.5/10

Dang, aight. When you say my renders are squished, what do you mean exactly?

 

[kstor1234]

that u have changed the size... for example the first one... it doesnt look good, like if u shrenk it a bit...

 

[Mreow]

Dang, aight. When you say my renders are squished, what do you mean exactly?

Squished as in.. how can I put it, squished. I can't explain. Lets just say look for better renders.

 

[kstor1234]

squished, you were changing the size of the render and it ended up bad... all ur renders look like that if u look good

they have good height, and bad width... its like u took width from them and not height, so it looks anormal... fix that

 

[Shagakrath]

I like the 3rd one, congratulations

 

[YouAreNotBob]

squished, you were changing the size of the render and it ended up bad... all ur renders look like that if u look good

they have good height, and bad width... its like u took width from them and not height, so it looks anormal... fix that

Alright, thanks man/woman, I'll try to keep that in mind on my next sig.

I like the 3rd one, congratulations

Yay

 

[jasonhwang]

Practice makes perfect .

 

[Laced]

Kinda like the others.

Very plain and dull to me :x

 

[Leimone]

imo none of them are good o.o

 

[buzzfizz]

The 3rd sig is kinda plain. Not much been done. Try playing around with filters to see the best outcome.

And liking the shoes lol.

 

[DrMido0o89]

they are not bad at all

 

[alexdesire]

1/10

Lacks allot of things i dont know where to start with it :/

 

[Rainwizzard]

I agree with fate... Find a new TUT