That's kinda messed up. rh-bin removed from my gdrive due to DMCA

Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
23
Reaction score
3
Well, this is kinda funny if you ask me.
Any way i can find out who was behind all this?

 

Attachments

You must be registered for see attachments list
Junior Spellweaver
Joined
Oct 12, 2013
Messages
128
Reaction score
10
Wtf? Does your rh-bin converter actually break any rules though?
 
Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
23
Reaction score
3
The thing is that's made by me ^^

What's there to break? I don't use any copyrighted content there.
 
Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
8
Reaction score
1
It's bcz you shared the link to public people it happend to me when i gave away a client on google drive they are asking for copyright on everything like names bin names etc everything that contains RH Rohan images and so on.
 
Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
23
Reaction score
3
That's fucked up. It's an editing tool, completely made by me.

If i'm to release the speedhack/cammode hack for iRohan, what would they do?
 
right + down + X
Loyal Member
Joined
May 25, 2006
Messages
1,688
Reaction score
298
They'd try to shut that down too. How would you like it if you made a game and invested millions into it, and some internet dudes came along and started writing hacks and private servers to let players enjoy your hard work without paying for it. You'd be mad about it, and you'd do everything you can to make it stop.

Your stuff or not, it's designed to break their terms of service
 
Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
8
Reaction score
1
They will spend more money updating the game guard if you release that or probbly just rename remove the commands from the rohanclient.exe
 
Experienced Elementalist
Joined
Feb 5, 2014
Messages
244
Reaction score
39
Reqveim

Were the files on your Google drive shared? If not, PlayWith had no business snooping around in it - regardless if they felt justified or not. Cloud contents are expected to be private with nobody but you and your designates accessing them. That is Google's TOS.

What you see there is a DMCA takedown order. In that takedown order the people making the complaint suspect, without proof, that what you posted violates their copyrights. They can do that. You can appeal that order with a DMCA Putback order (DMCA act section 512 (g) 2 and 3. (see scroll to section 'g' )


Here is some facts about your tool:

1. It reads binary files.
2. It translates binary files into new tab-separated-value (TSV) files.
3. It reads tab-separated-value (TSV) files.
4. It writes newly-created binary files.

Period. Nothing more. It :

(A) Does not modify code belonging to any other entity. It creates binary or TSV Files. Nothing more.
(B) You have no control of and are not responsible for what the user of that tool does with those new binary files (be sure to have a disclaimer ready!).

The facts here is that this code does not contain any code whatsoever belonging to YNK/Playwith. Nor does it modify existing code that belongs to YBNK/PlayWith. It is a tool and nothing more that belongs to you and you can prove you own all copyrights to that code.

In short you, as the owner of the removed material have the legal right to appeal this and insist on the file's replacement. You have full legal rights to distribute your code and YNK/PlayWith has no rights whatsoever in connection with your intellectual property.

One word of advice. Include a disclaimer of responsibility and liability when people use that tool. Cover your butt.

@GhostSnyper - Neither Reqveim or the end user has to certify agreement to Playwith's terms of service to distribute or run this tool

If the recipient of the output from this tool to modifies their client, then proceeds to play on PlayWith's servers with it, then THEY are the ones violating PlayWith's TOS. Not Reqveim or the person that created the files.

The PlayWith's TOS does not extend outside of their own online resources.
 
Last edited:
right + down + X
Loyal Member
Joined
May 25, 2006
Messages
1,688
Reaction score
298
I'm willing to bet my savings account that he had to download the official client at some point in order to make the tool. If he at ANY point opens the software for testing and sees an EULA(or similar), or has to accept the company's ToS to write/test the tool, he violates the law. I've had to deal with this poop and it's really annoying how it happens
 
Experienced Elementalist
Joined
Feb 5, 2014
Messages
244
Reaction score
39
Lol that's just it. You have to agree to the TOS when you create an account on their servers. You do not need an account to download the client. You do not need an account to extract its files or install it. When you RUN the client you see the copyright and license info and have to agree to it. BUT if you don't run the client or create an account, you are not bound by PlayWith's ToS.

Remember the burden of proof is on the accuser - not the accused. And once the putback orderr has been executed, Playwith can't issue another takedown without concrete proof.
 
right + down + X
Loyal Member
Joined
May 25, 2006
Messages
1,688
Reaction score
298
I guess you're right, but in the end, I'd rather just do what I've been doing... Find some offshore file host that doesn't bother with DCMA, or I just drop box it, since they really can't delete whats' on your computer, just disallow it to be shared (Until you change something)
 
Experienced Elementalist
Joined
Feb 5, 2014
Messages
244
Reaction score
39
Yes indeed.

While Req is fully within his rights to have Google put it back, why go thru all this garbage?
I doubt Req is independently wealthy to pay layers in the inevitable legal battles that would eventually arise if Mr Lee wants to get pissy & pursue it.

Best solution - Do all your files sharing offshore on places like (one of the best, but not cheap)
Next Best - Selectively share only to people you know & trust using ftp (turn server on only for the time you are sharing) - this is what I do.
Waste of time - Google Drive, Mega and just about every other 'cloud' service out there.
 
Newbie Spellweaver
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hi is there a ways you can share your RH-bin. ive been searching for days now and all the link are dead..